Bowhill Disaster - 31st October 1931
John Rattray Donaldson, colliery oversman, 48, married, Newton Cottages, Balgreggie Rd, Cardenden - cause of death carbon monoxide poisoning following burns of face & arms, shock
Charles Baxter Fernie, coalminer, 19, single, 4 First St, Bowhill - cause of death burns of face, arms & body, shock
William Ireland, colliery oversman, 35, single, Cluny Road, Cardenden -burns of face & hands, carbon monoxide poisoning, shock
James Drummond Paterson, coalminer (hewer), 19, single, 8 Eighth St, Bowhill - cause of death carbon monoxide poisoning following burns of face, arms & hands, shock
Andrew Smith, coalminer (hewer), 27, married, Long Rows, Denend, Cardenden, cause of death carbon monoxide poisoning following burns of face & arms
James Smith, coalminer (hewer), 35, single, 22 Sixteenth St, Bowhill, cause of death carbon monoxide poisoning following burns of face & arms, shock
Thomas Smith, coalminer (hewer), 33, married, 13 Ninth St, Cardenden - cause of death carbon monoxide poisoning following burns of face & arms, shock
Rescuers' Heroic Efforts - The men who were employed removing the position of a fan in the “Hutt Dook” section of the Dunfermline Splint, 5 foot seam, were killed as the result of an ignition of afterdamp. The accident took place between 11 and 12 o'clock, but it was not until 1.10 pm that the knowledge was flashed to the surface. Heroic rescue attempts were made by the members of other repair gangs at work elsewhere in the colliery, and by ambulance and rescue brigades from neighbouring collieries who volunteered their services, but their efforts were impeded by the presence of noxious gases, and although the bodies of the victims were located almost immediately after the accident it was not until seven o'clock on Sunday morning that the working parties reached the spot where the explosion had occurred.
The victims were:-
John Donaldson (49) oversman, 1 Newton Cottages, Cardenden
James Anderson (46) fireman, Balgreggie Park, Cardenden
Alexander Dempster (50) fireman, Helena Cottages, Cardenden
Andrew Smith (28) and Thomas Smith (33), miners, who were brothers, Long Row, Cardenden and 13 Ninth Street, Bowhill, respectively
James Smith (34), miner, 22 Sixteenth Street, Bowhill
James Paterson (19), miner, 8 Eighth Street, Bowhill
Charles Fernie (20) miner, 4 First Street, Bowhill
William Dodds (24) electrician, Woodend Park, Cardenden
William Ireland (35) oversman, Cluny Road, Cardenden
At once instructions were given for rescue brigades to be summoned from other Fife pits. Men from Cowdenbeath armed with the latest rescue apparatus arrived within seven minutes of the call being received. In all seven rescue teams under the direction of of Mr J J Ford, safety inspector, went down. Three local doctors went with them and the party was joined in the course of the evening by Mr Augustus Carlow, managing director of the Company; Mr C C Reid, general manager and his son Mr William Reid. Mr H M Foster, Mr H T Roberts, and Mr C A Groves, inspectors from the Ministry of Mines, were early opn the scene and went down the pit with the rescuers. Mr William Adamson, former Secretary of State for Scotland, drove from Dunfermline, and was underground until early on Saturday evening. He was accompanied by Mr James Potter of the Fife, Clackmannan, and Kinross Miners' Union.
The rescue party very soon found they had a heavy task in front of them. A high percentage of gas prevented them from getting anywhere near the scene of the explosion. Several canaries were taken down the main-level and the heading, but as all but one died almost at once it was considered unsafe for the rescuers to proceed until the gas had been cleared. The deaths of the birds indicated that there would be little or no hope for the ten men.
To remove the gas and prevent it from spreading it was necessary to reverse the air current. This formidable task involving the alteration of fans, was carried out by the rescue brigades wearing their heavy gas masks. The could proceed only very slowly, and it was well into the afternoon before the work was completed and the reversed air current commenced to drive the gas away by an outlet far from the rescuers.
Hours of anxious waiting ensured before any definite news came from the rescue parties to those at the pithead. And the news that came dispelled practically all hope that lingered among the relatives of the entombed men. Through great exertions the rescue party had got to within about 50 yards of the scene of the disaster, but beyond that point they could not go owing to the volumes of deadly fumes which lingered in the neighbourhood.
On one of the few occasions he came to the surface during the long battle for the dead, Mr C C Reid, almost exhausted, addressed the crowd of tense watchers. “I regret,” he said simply, “that all the men have perished.” A few women fainted on hearing the news, and were carried to tragic little homes in which the merriment of Hallowe'en should have reigned. Others drew their shawls or coats more tightly round them and continued their vigil.
Later, Mr Reid issued the following statement:- “I deeply regret that an accident occurred in the Bowhill Colliery to-day between 11 and 12 o'clock pm. Reports seem to point to the fact that an ignition of firedamp took place. The rescue men who have been down the pit have found the men, but unfortunately they are dead. We hope sometime during the early morning to bring the bodies to the surface.”
“We went down immediately we heard the news,” he said. “I did not know who the men were. All we knew was that some of our pals were down there. We had to get them out. It was an unnerving business. I have never been down before on such a job. After several hours we found some of the men's meal kits. That gave us hope. But the atmosphere was becoming terrible. We took down nine canaries, and when the last bird died we began to give up hope, I'm afraid, that any of the men might be alive. I should imagine we got to within 50 yards of where the entombed men might be, but we got no further. We were beaten completely by the atmosphere, and at last we had to give up.”
Another of the rescuers, Councillor John Bird, of Bowhill, described the finding of the bodies by the four masked safety men who were able to work ahead in the poisoned atmosphere. For hours they worked strenuously in carrying away the fall, which had completely blocked the section in which the men had been killed. “The safety men,” said Councillor Bird, “had to crawl on their hands and knees in order to reach them. To their horror they found nine men huddles together in a corner, while the tenth man was some distance off, having apparently been hurled away from the others by the force of the explosion.”
Shortly after eight o'clock on Saturday night word came to the surface that the bodies had at last been definitely discovered. Not the slightest hope could be given that any of the men survived - indeed, it was all too clear that all had perished in the first moments of the explosion. They had had no chance of escape. After this announcement most of the crowd went home, but here and there groups of miners remained throughout the night. A few occupied the time preparing a mortuary in one of the storerooms.
Bodies Brought To Surface
A great crowd of villagers, among whom were the relatives of the dead men, were waiting at the colliery. A storehouse near the pithead was used temporarily as a mortuary, and many of the women among the onlookers broke down as the stretchers bearing the dead men were carried from the pithead.
In the improvised mortuary the bodies were placed in coffins, and in the early afternoon the removal of the dead to their homes began. A hearse travelled back and forward between the colliery and the village ten times, taking the bodies one at a time. It was not until after four o'clock that the hearse made it's final journey.
King's Message of Sympathy - At 2.20 on Sunday afternoon the Rev A M'Neill Houston, minister of Auchterderran Parish Church received the following message from the King:- Buckingham Palace, The Queen and I are distressed to hear of the serious explosion in the Bowhill Colliery, and we offer the families of those who have perished our heartfelt sympathy in their suffering and tragic bereavement. George RI. The telegram was read at the afternoon and evening services at Auchterderran Church, and Dr Houston conveyed the King's message personally to the relatives of the dead men on Monday.
Premier's Message - Mr Ramsay MacDonald, the Prime Minister, on Monday sent the following telegram to Mr John Masterton, the Divisional Inspector of Mines in Edinburgh:- “I was very distressed to hear of the serious explosion at Bowhill Colliery. Will you please express my deepest sympathy with the families of those whose lives have been lost in this terrible accident?”
Sympathy with the widows and relatives of the deceased men was expressed on Monday at the meeting of the National Union of Scottish Mineworkers, held in Glasgow. Mr Jas Doonan, the president, who occupied the chair, referred to the recurrence of such accidents, and emphasised the risks undertaken by men of their dangerous calling. On his suggestion, a message of sympathy was sent to the Fife and Clackmannan Miners' Association.
Member of Parliament's Sympathy - Immediately he heard of the disaster Mr John Wallace MP, who is in London, got into telephone communication with the colliery, and later sent the following telegram to Provost Motion, Lochgelly:- “I was inexpressibly shocked when I heard today of the tragic occurrence at Bowhill Colliery, by which ten valuable lives have been lost, in spite of the gallant but unavailing efforts of the rescue parties. Will you please convey to the bereaved relatives an expression of my deepest sympathy with them in their irreparable loss? John Wallace”
Mr Wm Adamson and The Disaster - Mr William Adamson, who was interviewed said:- “It is the greatest disaster that had occurred in the Fife coalfield.” During his 58 years connection with industry he had not seen similar heart-rending scenes. “I could not get within 300 yards of the disaster,” said Mr Adamson, “and the news of the bodies having been found was conveyed to me by one of the rescue party. I cannot express in words my great grief at the calamity. Many of the men involved and their people had been associates of mine during the greater part of my public life. Calamitous as the disaster was many more lives would have been lost if the full number of men had been at work.”
Statement By Mr C C Reid. - Mr Reid, the manager, in an official statement issued to the press said:- “It was evident that there had been an ignition of gas, which in turn had generated afterdamp, although we do not yet know exactly how many men met their death. It took the rescuers many hours to erect fans to clear away the gas, but it is possible that the fate of the men was sealed when the ignition, which was the cause of the explosion, took place. The rescuers, who toiled unceasingly during the night, found the bodies lying in an area of twenty yards of roadway. This is the direst calamity which has occurred in the history of our Company.”
Inspection of Locus - About 11 o'clock on Monday forenoon the gas in the affected area was cleared sufficiently to permit of an inspection being made. Mr Charles C Reid and other colliery officials, accompanied by Mr John Masterton, Mr A K Horsely, HM Electrical Inspector of Mines for Great Britain, and three other mines inspectors, descended the pit to the scene of the accident. There were also three Union officials representing the relatives of the deceased men.
The party ascended the pit about 5.30pm but no statement was issued as to the result of their examination.
Mr C C Reid in an interview, said the locus had been thoroughly examined, but nothing had been determined as to what had caused the accident. Nothing would be known until the Mine Inspectors issued their official report, and an official inquiry held. The has had been driven out of the section and the position was normal.
The Funeral - The funeral of those who perished in the disaster took place in Wednesday. Shopkeepers carried on their business as usual until mid-day when shutters were put up and blinds drawn. Children continued to play in the streets, and housewives hurried on with their daily tasks, but over all hung an atmosphere of sorrow. The first real glimpse of it came at the main juncture of the Bowhill streets, where dozens of miners stood talking. Many of the pits in West Fife were idle, and the interments took place within a stone's throw of the pit where the men died. With one exception the victims of the disaster were buried side by side at the south end of the Bowhill cemetery. It was at first suggested that the men should be buried in one large grave, but after identification that suggestion was changed, and they were laid in separate graves, less than a hundred yards from the gates.
The only victim who was not interred at Bowhill was John Donaldson, whose remains were taken to his native Kingskettle.
A Moving Scene - Mr T Weeks, minister of St Fothad's, and several elders of the Church of Christ, took part in the private services in the homes of the men, after which the bodies of the nine men were taken to Denend School. The scene in the school playground was a deeply moving one, and many of the women present were in tears. Round the palings stood thousands of villagers, unable to gain entrance. Hundreds of floral wreaths and tributes were taken from the school cloakroom where they had been lying overnight, and placed in cars ready to join the funeral procession. Inside the square were the principal mourners, the Brass and Pipe Bands of Bowhill Colliery, and the Dundonald Pipe Band. After a scripture reading, Mr J C Robertson led the assembly in singing “Lead Kindly Light.”
After the service the Pipe Bands led off the funeral procession to the strains of “Scots Wha Hae.” From the school the cemetery is about a mile away, and as the procession slowly wended its way along every man in the crowd, which was estimated at about 10,000, doffed his hat in a tribute of respect.
Just as the cortege neared the cemetery, the sky darkened and rain fell, but immediately afterwards there came a brilliant burst of sunshine and a huge rainbow spread across the sky. The rain, however, was only delayed, and before the last coffin had been borne through the gate rain was falling heavily. The procession filed in to the strains of the “Land o' the Leal,” and the nine coffins were laid out in two rows - one of six and the other of three.
Mr William Maguire, a lay preacher at St Fothad's Mission conducted the committal service, and Rev Dr Houston gave the Benediction prayer. The nine coffins were lowered amidst an impressive hush. It was almost impossible to hear the service from any distance, the wind rendering the loud speakers, which were erected in the cemetery, practically useless.
Among those present were:- Mr Charles A Carlow, managing director of the Fife Coal Company; Mr C C Reid, general manager; Mr John Clarke, colliery manager; Mr Jas. Calder, colliery agent; Mr William Adamson, ex-Secretary of State for Scotland; Mr William Watson, ex-MP for Dunfermline Burgh; and Mr Charles Milne, MP for West Fife. [Dunfermline Journal & West Fife Echo 7 November 1931]
Account of Allan Hutt, in charge of the ambulance department at the Colliery
One of the clearest statements concerning the disaster was given to a representative of The Scotsman by Mr Allan Hutt, who is in charge of the ambulance department at the colliery. Mr Hutt gave a detailed account of the rescue work. He was among the first men to go down into the mine after the news of the disaster had reached the surface, and did not come up to the pithead again until nearly 24 hours later, when the bodies were brought to the surface.
A Mile From The Shaft - The point where the explosion occurred, explained Mr Hutt, was about a mile from the foot of the shaft. The 10 men had been engaged in moving an electric fan from one point of the pit to another, the purpose of the fan being to drive out explosive gas from that part of the pit which was known as a safety lamp section - a section, that is, where it was essential to work with safety lamps. It was situated at the end of a gallery 300 yards long running eastwards from the bottom of the long "dook", a sloping roadway. The task of the working parties was hindered not so much by falling debris as by the deadly gases - carbon monoxide and others - generated by the explosion. The only men who could reach the entombed party were the masked rescue brigade, specially trained for the work, and able to penetrate into poisonous areas. The ambulance men and others, who were unmasked, concentrated in arranging fans at the foot of the dook and at the entrance to the section at the end of which the men had been killed. By arranging two fans blowing fresh air into the section and another acting as a suction fan to draw air and gas out through another gallery, the task of clearing the atmosphere was accomplished. This was a long and difficult piece of work, which went on steadily all through the night, and it was not until 10 o'clock yesterday morning that the air was sufficiently pure to enable the workers to reach the point where the bodies were lying.
With the conditions now made possible for the final task of taking the bodies to the surface, the stretchers were carried right in to a point near the place where the dead men had been found. The bodies were then conveyed to the stretchers and carried out one by one.
Possible Cause Examined - A point of great importance was discussed by Mr Hutt. A theory had been considered that the explosion might be due to the ignition of inflammable gas by electric spark in some part of the mechanism of the fan the which the men were engaged in moving from one position to another. In order to move the fan it had been necessary to disconnect it for some time, and the quantity of gas would be liable to collect in the section during the time when the fan was not in operation.
It was thought possible at first that a spark in the motor or at the plug might have caused the explosion. This theory however was discountenanced by the discovery of which was made at the foot of the dook that the wire leading to the electric fan was not plugged in at the distributor situated at the entrance to the section, and that therefore, even although the fan had been reconnected by the men working at the end of the section, it would still be "dead" and not capable of operating. The cause of the explosion therefore, remained unexplained.
“Of the 10 men,” said Mr Hutt in discussing their injuries, “some had evidently been killed outright by the explosion, and the rest had been burned to death. In every case death must have been very rapid". [Scotsman 2 November 1931]
A pathetic feature of the death roll is the fact that the widow of Thomas Smith, the contractor in the run, who is left with two small children, has lost her husband, her brother (Charles Fernie), and her brother-in -law (Andrew Smith). [Scotsman 2 November 1931]
10 November 1931
Fraud Echo Of Fife Pit Disaster - A Lochore miner, who represented that he was collecting subscriptions in aid of the dependants of the men killed in the Bowhill Colliery disaster, was sent to prison for 20 days at Kinross Sheriff Court yesterday. The accused, Alexander Dow, Waverley Cottages, Lochore, Fife, pleaded guilty to having falsely represented that he was authorised to collect subscriptions on behalf of the dependants of the deceased in the Bowhill disaster, and with having appropriated to his own use 30s., which he had collected in the village of Scotlandwell. Hon. Sheriff-Substitute Brown, in passing sentence, said that accused in taking advantage of the serious position and plight of the poor people in Bowhill had committed one of the most contemptible and meanest frauds imaginable. [Scotsman 11 November 1931]
26 January 1932
Deputy Sheriff Umpherston and jury which included 3 women, concluded the enquiry at Dunfermline yesterday into the pit explosion which nearly 3 months ago led to the deaths of 10 miners at Bowhill Colliery, Fife.
The jury found that the deaths were due to an ignition and explosion of firedamp but they were unable to assign any cause to it. They warmly commended the bravery of the rescue workers. In particular they described as being worthy of the highest traditions the conduct of James Clark, and overman who seeing a glimmer of light some distance along the coal face, crawled without any lamp to detect gas until he reached the glimmer and found the body of a man who was still breathing. He was unable to move the body down the coal face, so returned for assistance. With a safety lamp he crawled back a long the coal face until his lamp filled with firedamp and was extinguished, compelling him to give up his attempt at rescue.
The jury recommended that the section in which the explosion occurred should be provided with an auxiliary fan which ought to be in constant operation; that all electrical apparatus in the section should be constructed and maintained in a flame proof condition; and that electric lamps carried by miners should be encased with laminated triplex glass. [Scotsman 26 January 1932]